Past Issues
Art History Home

Links & Events

Ben Shahn's Two Portraits of Walker Evans: A Critique Painted

 
  Androgyny and the Mirror: Photographs of Florence Henri,
1927-38
by Melody Davis
 
  Betwixt and Between: Female Portraiture in the Work of Nadar
by Jennifer E. Farrell
   
  Mathieu Paints a Picture
by Fred Gross
   
  Ben Shahn's Two Portraits of Walker Evans: A Critique Painted
by Jin Han
   
  Taking Inventory: William Henry Fox Talbot
by Lisa Jaye Young
   
 
  Big Impact
by Katherine Bussard
   
  New York September 11 by Magnum Photographers
by Tina Gregory
   
  The Beauty of Evil? review of on european ground by Alan Cohen
by Allison Moore
   
  "La Divine Comtesse": Photographs of the Countess de Castiglione
by Caterina Pierre
   
  Letizia Battaglia: Passion Justice Freedom - Photographs of Sicily
by Marguerite Shore
   
  From Gothic to Modern: the Faces/Facades of Roland Fischer
by Sarah Stanley
   
  Luke Smalley, "Gymnasium"
by Rich Turnbull
   
 
   
 
  Exhibition Design as Installation Piece
by Vanessa Rocco
   
  Editor's Note
 
by Jin Han
 
 

1. Frances K. Pohl, Ben Shahn (San Francisco: Pomegranate Artbooks, 1993), 10.

2. Walker Evans. Quoted in Morris Dorsky, “The Formative Years of Ben Shahn: The Origin and Development of His Style” (MA Thesis, Institution of Fine Art, New York University, 1966), 49.

3. Pohl, 8.

4. Evans observed of Shahn that he was “a Brooklyn boy who didn’t want to be a lithographer.” Quoted in Dorsky, 48.

5. In 1925 and from 1927 to 1929 he traveled in Europe and North Africa.

6. Ben Shahn, Interview by Dorsky, October 7, 1951. In Dorsky, 9.

7. Quoted in Dorsky, Ibid.

8. Dorsky, Ibid.

9. John Szarkowski, Introduction in Walker Evans, Walker Evans (New York: The Museum of Modern Art, 1971), 9.

10. Berlinda Rathbone, Walker Evans: A Biography (Boston: Houghton Mifflin Company, 1995), 35-6.

11. Pohl, 10.

12. Walker Evans, Walker Evans at Work (New York: Harper & Row, Publishers 1982), 24.

13. Quoted in Walker Evans at Work, 70.

14. Dorsky, 45.

15. Rathbone, 54; Bernarda Bryson Shahn recalled, “When I first knew Shahn in 1933, they had two studios in the old house at Bethune Street and a lot of people were coming and going.” Bernarda Bryson Shahn, interview by the author, Roosevelt, New Jersey, October 21, 1996.

16. Rathbone, 54.

17. Ibid.

18. Bernarda Bryson Shahn, interview by the author, Roosevelt, New Jersey, October 21, 1996.

19. Twelve of Shahn’s photographs were published in the November 1934 issue of New Theater magazine in a photo essay titled, “The Theatre of New York.” Susan Edwards, “Ben Shahn: A New Deal Photographer In The Old South” (Ph.D. diss., The Graduate Center, The City University of New York, 1996), 35.

20. Ibid, 38.

21. John D. Morse, ed. Ben Shahn (London: Secker and Warburg, 1972), 135.

22. Rathbone observed that the portrait in watercolor was done in the summer of 1930, although both portraits were dated 1931 in the books by Bernarda Bryson Shahn and Frances K. Pohl. Rathbone, 55; Mrs. Shahn herself was not sure about the exact date of the portraits yet she believed that the watercolor portrait was painted later than the oil portrait. Bernarda Bryson Shahn, interview by the author, Ibid.

23. Shahn stated about portraiture: “The first problem having to do with likeness in portraiture is that of whether one is primarily a portrait painter, or whether he is primarily a painter, as such. I have a notion that the principal difficulty facing the professional portrait painter is one of personalities. Indeed, every sitter for a portrait has a thousand faces, and the one that he wants to see appear on the canvas is his most comely face—probably imaginary, at that. If his portraitist is inclined to candor, the sitter may be deeply grieved; he may, I am sure that he often does, reject the work on the ground that it does not resemble him. Ben Shahn, “Concerning ‘Likeness’ in Portraiture.” Quoted in Morse, 88.

24. Bernarda Bryson Shahn, interview by the author, Ibid.

25. Quoted in Pohl, 10.

26. Rathbone, 55.

27. Quoted in Dorsky, 49.

28. Quoted in Walker Evans at Work, 42.

29. However, Shahn’s increasing interest in the lives of ordinary people in the late thirties had more to do with his career as an active documentary photographer for the Resettlement Administration/Farm Security Administration in 1935 and ‘36. In the fall of 1935, under government patronage, Shahn took a three-month trip to photograph the rural South. Through this trip, he was drawn to the folk culture of ordinary people, a change “from a social realist to a personal realist.” Ben Shahn, The Shape of Content (Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1957), 40.

Back>>
 

 
 
Home
  © 2002 PART and Jin Han. All Rights Reserved.