Robert Smithson: Language to be Looked At and/or Things to be Read, Drawings from 1962-63
by Robin Clark

"Robert Smithson: Language to be Looked at and/or Things to be Read, Drawings from 1962-63"
James Cohan Gallery
February 5 - March 4, 2000

A spate of exhibitions featuring sculptors' drawings demonstrates the fluidity with which artists worked across media during the 1960s and 1970s. Recent group and monographic shows highlighting works on paper by Gordon Matta-Clark, Eva Hesse, Sol Lewitt, Nancy Holt and Robert Smithson attest to both the richness of this material and the current appetite for it.1 No one in this community of artists exploited the permeable boundaries between two and three dimensions, or dialectical relationships between words, images and objects, as thoroughly as Robert Smithson.

click to see larger view

For this reason it is fortunate that "Robert Smithson: Language to be Looked at and/or Things to be Red, Drawings from 1962-63," held this spring at James Cohan Gallery, focused on Smithson's early works on paper. It served as an important complement to the shows mentioned above, some of which dealt with Smithson's better-known work in minimal and process-oriented idioms from the later 1960s. The Cohan Gallery show reopens provocative questions posed in the last decade by scholars including Caroline Jones and Eugenie Tsai. How should we read Smithson's text-emblazoned drawings and collages from the early 1960s? And what relationship might this work (which was later rejected by Smithson and critics alike as juvenilia) have to his tremendously influential production during the later 1960s and early 1970s? 2

A majority of the works displayed in the Cohan Gallery show are free hand ink drawings that foreground an interplay between text and cartoon-like images. The simultaneously hieroglyphic, pictographic, and phonetic possibilities of words as material are explored in works such as No Vacancy, 1962. The title phrase of this drawing is rendered in an overwrought schoolboy script, while the tawdry pleasures imagined within are described by the word "VASELINE" exclaimed 52 times on the top third of the sheet. Compulsive repetition as ritual and ornament play out in a grid of 11 x 26 5-pointed stars, and in the form of an expressionless female nude, outlined by the text "butter on velvet," repeated five times below. Smithson's proclivity for marrying banal and apocalyptic themes during this period is demonstrated by the incantation "Price War Last Day" inscribed like a doomsday pediment across the bottom of the page.

click to see larger view

Of the 31 works on paper included in the exhibition, six of the densest and most complex pieces are collages. Tension between center and periphery, a dynamic later developed more rigorously in Smithson's theory of site and nonsite, is humorously explored in St. John in the Desert, c. 1961-63. At multiple removes from its source, the central image is a cut-out mechanical reproduction of an etching after Raphael, representing a scantily clad boy in leopard skin. This winsome St. John is surrounded by diagrams of cathode resistors, audio output recorders, and various types of circuits apparently clipped from a user's manual. The text in these diagrams is rife with organic/mechanical metaphor -- "good fuse, bad fuse" -- and advice of dubious value to St. John -- "how we put a magnetic field on tape." Technical drawings engulf Raphael's mage like improbable marginalia; clearly neither can explain the other, yet in their absurdity both the saint and the gadgets are presented as objects of desire.

The exhibition title, "Language to be Looked at and/or Things to be Read," was lifted from a Dwan Gallery press release drafted by Smithson (under the pseudonym Eton Corrasable) in 1967. The drawing that accompanied that press release (A Heap of Language, 1966) was not included in the Cohan Gallery show, but Smithson's published work from that period was represented by the inclusion of two magazine articles displayed in a vitrine.3 Both of these works, as examples of Smithson's polemic ruminations on art and history, reward sustained attention beyond the
click to see larger view
scope of this review. However, the most persuasive argument in the show for connections between Smithson's early drawings and his later three-dimensional works is perhaps to be found in another collage, Conch Shell Spaceship and Word Land Mass, 1961-63. Three quarters of this vertically-oriented work is populated with a proliferation of nouns and proper names -- "Gorgon," "OHARA," "things," "Lyme" -- scrawled in crayon which has been overwashed with black gouache. Figure and ground struggle for dominance in this "word land mass." The text, rendered in oil crayon, repels the water-based gouache, but where the crayon line is thin it is overwhelmed by dark painted pigment so that the text is in turn sublimated. The inversion of figure and ground, the elision of words and matter (or the emergence of words as matter), and the science fiction elements of Conch Shell Spaceship and Word Land Mass are themes fruitfully explored in Smithson's later work, such as Spiral Jetty, 1970. Variously realized as a monumental earthwork, an experimental film, a parodic essay, and sheaves of drawings ranging from rough concept sketches to carefully scaled engineering plans, Spiral Jetty may seem too elaborate a project to compare to this humble collage. Yet, rather than positing a simple causal relationship between the drawings and collages from 1961-63 and works in three dimensions from 1966-1973, the works in this exhibition provide an opportunity to examine Smithson's preliminary forays into a thicket of complex ideas. While affinities between the early collages and drawings and Smithson's later projects are intriguing, these works even more telling as evidence of what he left behind in the construction of his mature, self-described oeuvre.

 

© 2000 Part and Robin Clark. All Rights Reserved.